Skip to main content

Woolf's Criticism of Treatment of the Mentally Ill in Mrs. Dalloway

          The treatment of mental illness seems to be a recurring theme in my writing throughout this year. Indeed, during Woolf’s and Faulkner’s writing years, many young men were returning from the Great War (World War I) and had seen unprecedented amounts of horror and violence. To worsen matters, in society, there were little to no resources for war veterans coping with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), which was referred to as “shell shock” at the time. In Mrs. Dalloway, Virginia Woolf uses Septimus Warren Smith to bring to light the poor treatment of war veterans. She presents two doctors with differing views, Sir William Bradshaw and Dr. Holmes, but both ineffective, in order to criticize the cruel treatment of the mentally ill.
            At first, Sir Bradshaw seems to be caring. After all, Woolf describes him as “understanding of the human soul” (95). Moreover, Bradshaw appears to disapprove of Dr. Holmes’s work, for he states, “It took half his time to undo their [general practitioners such as Dr. Holmes] blunders” (95). However, as Septimus and Rezia spend more time with Bradshaw, the readers begin to understand his own flaws. Bradshaw suggests that the best way to “cure” Septimus is to isolate him from everyone he knows and to place him in one of Bradshaw’s homes. This diagnosis presents many issues. On one level, Bradshaw attempts to place Septimus in one of his own homes, which would be very expensive for Septimus and very profitable for Bradshaw. On another level, Bradshaw admits that he tries to keep all his patients in accordance with his own “proportions,” meaning values, and sends away those who disagree. He thinks, “[he] made England prosper, secluded her lunatics, forbade childbirth, penalised despair, made it impossible for the unfit to propagate their views until they, too, shared his sense of proportion” (99). Thus, Woolf portrays Bradshaw to be selfish, judgmental, and hungry for power.
            Equally as unsettling is the character of Dr. Holmes. Dr. Holmes completely misunderstands the gravity of PTSD, and instead considers Septimus a coward for contemplating suicide and worrying his wife. He constantly suggests that all Septimus must do is find a hobby. Septimus’s hatred for Dr. Holmes’s becomes most clearly evident as he commits suicide. As he hears Dr. Holmes approaching, he thinks, “He would wait till the very last moment. He did not want to die. Life was good” (149). Yet, as soon as he sees the doctor, he jumps over the railings. Rather than helping Septimus’s illness, Dr. Holmes’s presence itself seems to drive Septimus over the edge.

            Through these two ineffective doctors, Woolf criticizes English society’s treatment of veterans and the mentally ill.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Allusions in Song of Solomon

           Song of Solomon is peppered with many different allusions. Ranging from classical myths to traditional folk tales, these stories enhance the text and establish parallels between Morrison’s characters and well-known figures. One such allusion is the Brothers’ Grimm tale of “Hansel and Gretel.” At the start of Part II in the novel, Morrison describes the tale of “Hansel and Gretel” and compares the two children’s journey to Milkman searching for Circe’s home. In “Hansel and Gretel,” two children abandoned in the woods by their parents who cannot afford to care for them anymore come across a witch’s house from which they must escape after she attempts to eat them. The story reflects an era’s financial hardships, but also a loss of innocence for Hansel and Gretel. “Hansel and Gretel” functions in Song of Solomon in two different ways. First of all, Macon and Pilate are Hansel and Gretel. After all, their beloved father is killed by racists, and the...
Post a Comment
Read more

Interesting Metaphors in Song of Solomon

Toni Morrison’s novel Song of Solomon is peppered with many different unusual metaphors. Often appearing at unexpected moments, this figurative language enhances the text and offers more meaning into the characters’ minds. The following are a few of my favorite metaphors: “There was the pain and shame of seeing his father crumple before any man–even himself. Sorrow in discovering that the pyramid was not five-thousand-year wonder of the civilized world, mysteriously and permanently constructed by generation after generation of hardy men who had died in order to perfect it, but that it had been made in the back room at Sears, by a clever window dresser, of papier-maché, guaranteed to last a lifetime” (68) In this passage, Milkman reflects on hitting his father after Macon abuses Ruth. The act of retaliation represents Milkman’s loss of innocence and transition into full adulthood; he realizes that he no longer fears his father. Prior to this moment, his father, like the pyramid, is...
Post a Comment
Read more

"The Headstrong Historian": an Homage to Things Fall Apart

In her short story “The Headstrong Historian,” Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie pays tribute to Chinua Achebe’s novel Things Fall Apart while adding her own distinct voice. Like Achebe’s classic novel, “The Headstrong Historian” paints rich portraits of Nigerian tribal culture before the advent of white missionaries and the Nigerians who grapple with culture clashes and changes. The short story immediately establishes its ties to Things Fall Apart when it mentions that the character “Obierika”–a name which readers may recognize as the close friend of Achebe’s protagonist Okonkwo–is the late husband of Adichie’s protagonist Nwamgba (198). Moreover, when Nwamgba and Obierika struggle to conceive a child, Nwamgba “suggests he go and see the Okonkwo family about their daughter” as a potential wife and mother to his child (204). These developments create the expectation that the short story will have a similar, if not identical, narrative to Things Fall Apart : that the advent of the white missio...
Post a Comment
Read more